Proposal Strategy
May 30, 2025

Why Your Proposal Process Is Killing Your Close Rate (And What to Do About It)

Joe Ardeeser
Founder & CEO, Smart Pricing Table

Is your proposal process silently destroying your sales?

You’ve had the calls. You’ve qualified the lead. You’ve even had that “this could be big” feeling in your gut. Then… silence. The proposal goes out, and it’s like you launched it into space.

Here’s the cold truth: If you’re not closing deals consistently, your proposal process might be the real culprit.

Let’s unpack the hidden ways your proposals are sabotaging your close rate—and how to fix them without rewriting your entire sales process.

Problem #1: Proposals take too long

Speed matters. A lot.

When proposals take days (or weeks) to build, momentum dies. Prospects cool off. Projects stall. And suddenly you’re following up with “just checking in” emails that go unanswered.

If you’re reinventing the wheel every time, it’s not just inefficient—it’s risky. You lose time and attention.

Problem #2: Vague scopes = vague decisions

Most proposals are just polished versions of “uh… we’ll figure it out.”

When you’re unclear on what’s included and what’s not, you create anxiety. And anxious buyers don’t buy. They stall. They nitpick. Or worse—they ghost.

Clear, modular pricing with defined deliverables gives prospects the confidence to move forward. It shows professionalism. It says, “We’ve done this before.”

Problem #3: No optionality, no ownership

Here’s the sales secret nobody tells you:

The moment your prospect feels like they’re in control of the deal… they’re more likely to close.

Proposals that include optional upsells let buyers choose their own adventure. They feel empowered. They upsell themselves.

Want the strategy session? Click. Want quarterly reports? Add it. No pressure. No pushy pitch. Just options.

The fix: A smarter way to propose

If your proposal process is slow, vague, and rigid, you’re making it harder for clients to say yes.

Here’s what to do:

  • Build a catalog of reusable services with clear scope and pricing
  • Let clients choose optional items to increase deal size and engagement
  • Use a platform that’s built for agencies, not generic PDF templates

That’s exactly what Smart Pricing Table does.
We help agencies create faster, clearer, more flexible proposals—so you can stop chasing deals and start closing them.

👉 Learn more or book a no-obligation demo

Recent Posts